In December 1912, the Santa Ana Register ran an article describing a Christmas celebration at the home of my grandparents, Gilbert and Beatrice [Lockwood] Bates. Of the twenty-two attendees, at least twenty-one were close family members who had moved from Michigan to California (see Migration – From Michigan to California ).
Dinner And A Tree
The Christmas celebration took place when Beatrice and Gilbert lived in Santa Ana, well before they moved to Ramona in early 1917 and eventually to Valley Center in 1921. My father Edgar L. was not born until a year later.

Attendees
The dinner must have been quite an event, and a chance for all the relatives from Michigan to get together again. Listed below are the details of how they were related.
- Gilbert E. Bates and Beatrice E. Lockwood: the host and hostess, my paternal grandparents
- Mr. and Mrs. Frank J. Holman: Beatrice’s parents, Franklin J. Holman and Julia A. Spicer
- Mr. and Mrs. A. L. Hardy: Gilbert’s sister, Martha J. Bates and husband Arthur (Art) L. Hardy
- Mr. and Mrs. Claude Cochran: Martha and Art’s daughter Grace E. Cochran and husband Claude H. Cochran
- Donald Cochran: Grace and Claude’s son Donald C. Cochran, age about 2 1/2 months
- Mr. and Mrs. Chas. Bates: Gilbert’s brother Charles F. Bates and his wife Myrtle B. Hill
- Willie Bates: Charles and Myrtle’s son William A. Bates
- Mr. & Mrs. Clifford Schroer: Gilbert’s sister Lottie M. Bates and husband Clifford E. Schroer
- W. H. Bates: Gilbert’s father William H. Bates
- Mrs. Ostrander: Beatrice’s aunt Iora Kopp Lockwood Ostrander, visiting from Michigan
- Mrs. R. L. Lockwood: Beatrice’s mother Mayrennie (Rennie) Holman (later Shaw)
- H. S. Lockwood: Beatrice’s brother Homer S. Lockwood
- Bertha Bates: Gilbert’s sister Bertha E. Bates, later married Frank Miller
- Clarence Bates: Gilbert and Beatrice’s eldest son, age 3 years
- Clifford Bates: Gilbert and Beatrice’s next eldest son, age 1 1/2 years
- Chas Martin: I’m not certain who this was.
A Second Clipping

Two days later the same newspaper again mentioned that the Holmans had attended the Christmas dinner gathering.
Mike, That’s amazing you could track the story down. You are quite a researcher.
Thanks, Dick. Maybe some Hollingsworth posts this year.